Rob, sorry no 4+ or Hybrid 5 users have responded, i know they are out there. Maybe take a trip to your local golf retail store who should have both styles on the floor that you can do a direct comparison. I went with the Players 4 because I wanted the lightest possible and didn't need the additional large side pocket. I love mine. Hybrid 5 is still under 5 lbs so not too heavy to carry if you don't load it down with too much stuff. Can't go wrong with whichever one you choose.

I have been going back and forth myself on these exact two bags. Was thinking of having it before the Whistling Straits trip. I currently have the the 2016 caddy bag that I bought before the Pinehurst event, to lighten the load on the caddy there. If I can't make up my mind, I'll just end up using it.

I did as Dale recommended and happened to find a 4+ bag at my local Golfmart. I think I’m going to order a customer 4+ and keep my Hybrid 5 as my backup bag.

I’m not sure if this is post-allowable or not, but on the golf reddit page someone said they went to a goodwill shop and bought this bag for $10, well 9.99 actually. Looks like they made out pretty nice.