I have same bag with no issues. Are you saying it breaks clubs in normal use? Only issue where a had breakage is when I got mad and threw my club towards my bag and then broke clubs when it hit. LOL..

Be careful with having graphite shafts in the bag holes left and right where the plastic handle is. :)

It doesn’t sound like your club is actually ‘broken’ due to bag ‘chatter.’ While the wear to the base graphite (the orange is just a paint layer) will not hinder performance, I understand how aggravating it can be. I’ve had similar issues and it can be fixed (carefully) with touch up paint. Try to match the color to model paint or sharpie from a craft store. It won’t be perfect, but you can get close. When you have the color right, give the area a light spray with clear acrylic (satin or matte matches most shaft finishes. When you’re at the craft store, buy some craft felt or craft foam with an adhesive backing and cover the shaft contact area of the plastic on the bag collar.